Annual fee audit
The annual fee audit
Every year, your cards charge you for the privilege of carrying them — and hand you a pile of credits to make up for it. The issuers count on you never adding it up. So we did, for all 76 annual-fee cards in our catalog: $21,249 in combined yearly fees, set against $31,744.20 in counted credits.
The result is not a sales pitch. 43 cards cover their fee on counted credits alone. 33 do not — including some of the most famous cards on the market. Both lists are below, with every number shown.
How this audit counts (read this before the table)
- Counted: a benefit with a verified dollar amount on a repeating cycle, at its full yearly rate. A $10 monthly credit counts as $120. The Global Entry credit counts as $30 a year — $120 spread over its four-year cycle.
- Not counted: points and miles (we never put a dollar figure on them — what they're worth depends on how you use them); free-night awards and lounge memberships and status (no listed dollar value); per-booking credits (they depend on how often you travel); and any benefit our catalog hasn't finished verifying. Those things have real value. They are simply not credits, so they don't get to defend the fee here.
- The face-value warning: the counted column assumes you use every credit, in full, every cycle. Almost nobody does. A card "passing" this audit means the money is there to take — not that you took it. A card failing it can still be worth keeping for the uncounted things. What the audit kills is the excuse: now you can see exactly which credits have to get used for your fee to make sense.
- A few counted credits require hitting a spending threshold first (a voucher after $30,000 of spend, for example). They are counted at face value, and our catalog notes the threshold on the card's own page.
The cards that fail their own audit
Capital One Venture X — $395 fee, $330 counted (−$65). The most surprising result on this page. The $300 travel credit and the Global Entry credit are all that count; the 10,000 anniversary miles and the lounge access carry the rest of the card's case, uncounted by design. If you don't use the lounges, this card is underwater on credits alone.
Mastercard Gold Card (Barclays) — $1,199 fee, $730 counted (−$469). The most expensive card in the catalog, and the largest dollar shortfall: a $300 airline credit, $200 dining credit, $200 Ship&Play credit and the application-fee credit add up to $730 — and the remaining $469 of fee has to be justified by things this audit doesn't price.
Emirates Skywards Premium (Barclays) — $499 fee, $24 counted (−$475). Almost nothing on this card takes a dollar value at all — its case rests entirely on miles and status, which this audit doesn't price.
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant (Amex) — $650 fee, $300 counted (−$350). A $25-a-month dining credit is the only counted benefit. The annual Free Night Award is the card's real defense, and it is deliberately uncounted here — no listed dollar value. If you don't use that night, the math is the math.
Atmos Rewards Summit (Bank of America) — $395 fee, $30 counted (−$365). Just the application-fee credit, annualized. Everything else on the card carries no counted dollar value — miles and status, which this audit doesn't price.
U.S. Bank Altitude Reserve — $400 fee, $0 counted (−$400). An honest zero: our catalog lists this card's travel and dining credit as not yet verified, so this audit counts it as $0 until the verification finishes. We would rather show a zero we can explain than a number we haven't checked.
Delta SkyMiles Reserve (Amex) — $650 fee, $560 counted (−$90) and Bank of America Premium Rewards Elite — $550 fee, $480 counted (−$70): close, but short — one forgotten monthly credit cycle is the whole difference.
The full table — all 76 annual-fee cards
| Card | Annual fee | Counted credits/yr | Ahead / behind |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platinum Card from American Express for Morgan Stanley | $895 | $3,869.40 | +$2,974.40 |
| Amex Platinum Card | $895 | $3,004.40 | +$2,109.40 |
| Platinum Card from American Express for Schwab | $895 | $2,974.40 | +$2,079.40 |
| Chase Sapphire Reserve | $795 | $2,090.00 | +$1,295.00 |
| Iberia Visa Signature Card | $95 | $1,120.00 | +$1,025.00 |
| Citi AAdvantage Executive World Legend Mastercard | $695 | $1,430.00 | +$735.00 |
| British Airways Visa Signature Card | $95 | $720.00 | +$625.00 |
| United Quest Card | $350 | $886.00 | +$536.00 |
| United Explorer Card | $150 | $560.00 | +$410.00 |
| Citi Strata Elite Card | $595 | $930.00 | +$335.00 |
| Caesars Rewards Prestige Visa Signature Card | $149 | $450.00 | +$301.00 |
| Disney Inspire Visa Card | $149 | $420.00 | +$271.00 |
| Delta SkyMiles Gold American Express Card | $150 | $420.00 | +$270.00 |
| Hilton Honors American Express Aspire Card | $550 | $819.00 | +$269.00 |
| IHG One Rewards Premier Credit Card | $150 | $400.00 | +$250.00 |
| Citi Strata Premier Card | $95 | $316.00 | +$221.00 |
| IHG One Rewards Premier Select Credit Card | $350 | $550.00 | +$200.00 |
| United Club Card | $695 | $884.00 | +$189.00 |
| Chase Sapphire Preferred | $95 | $250.00 | +$155.00 |
| Citizens Summit Reserve World Elite Mastercard | $295 | $426.00 | +$131.00 |
| Royal ONE Plus Visa Signature Credit Card | $99 | $230.00 | +$131.00 |
| Citi AAdvantage Globe Mastercard | $350 | $470.00 | +$120.00 |
| Amex Gold Card | $325 | $424.00 | +$99.00 |
| Disney Premier Visa Card | $49 | $120.00 | +$71.00 |
| Amex Classic Green Card | $150 | $219.00 | +$69.00 |
| Hilton Honors American Express Surpass Card | $150 | $200.00 | +$50.00 |
| Delta SkyMiles Platinum American Express Card | $350 | $390.00 | +$40.00 |
| USAA Eagle Navigator Credit Card | $95 | $130.00 | +$35.00 |
| One Key+ Card | $99 | $130.00 | +$31.00 |
| Bank of America Premium Rewards | $95 | $125.00 | +$30.00 |
| Citi AAdvantage Platinum Select World Elite Mastercard | $99 | $125.00 | +$26.00 |
| World of Hyatt Credit Card | $95 | $120.00 | +$25.00 |
| Marriott Bonvoy Boundless Credit Card | $95 | $120.00 | +$25.00 |
| Amex Blue Cash Preferred | $95 | $120.00 | +$25.00 |
| Aer Lingus Visa Signature Card | $95 | $120.00 | +$25.00 |
| Wyndham Rewards Earner Premier Card | $395 | $415.00 | +$20.00 |
| PenFed Pathfinder Rewards Visa Signature Card | $95 | $100.00 | +$5.00 |
| Navy Federal Flagship Premier Visa Signature Card | $95 | $100.00 | +$5.00 |
| Atmos Rewards Ascent Visa Signature Card | $95 | $99.00 | +$4.00 |
| JetBlue Plus Card | $99 | $100.00 | +$1.00 |
| Hawaiian Airlines Bank of Hawaii World Elite Mastercard | $99 | $100.00 | +$1.00 |
| Frontier Airlines World Mastercard | $99 | $100.00 | +$1.00 |
| Harley-Davidson H.O.G. Elite Visa Signature Card | $99 | $99.00 | $0.00 |
| Citi Prestige | $495 | $280.00 | −$215.00 |
| Emirates Skywards Premium World Elite Mastercard | $499 | $24.00 | −$475.00 |
| Mastercard Black Card | $699 | $330.00 | −$369.00 |
| Mastercard Gold Card | $1,199 | $730.00 | −$469.00 |
| Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express Card | $650 | $300.00 | −$350.00 |
| Atmos Rewards Summit Visa Infinite Card | $395 | $30.00 | −$365.00 |
| U.S. Bank Altitude Reserve | $400 | $0.00 | −$400.00 |
| Delta SkyMiles Reserve American Express Card | $650 | $560.00 | −$90.00 |
| Bank of America Premium Rewards Elite | $550 | $480.00 | −$70.00 |
| Korean Air SKYPASS Select Visa Signature Card | $450 | $380.00 | −$70.00 |
| Capital One Venture X | $395 | $330.00 | −$65.00 |
| Capital One Venture X Business | $395 | $330.00 | −$65.00 |
| Chase Air Canada Aeroplan Credit Card | $195 | $130.00 | −$65.00 |
| Choice Privileges Select Mastercard | $95 | $30.00 | −$65.00 |
| Capital One Venture | $95 | $30.00 | −$65.00 |
| Marriott Bonvoy Bevy American Express Card | $250 | $0.00 | −$250.00 |
| Marriott Bonvoy Bountiful Credit Card | $250 | $120.00 | −$130.00 |
| Southwest Rapid Rewards Priority Credit Card | $229 | $120.00 | −$109.00 |
| Southwest Rapid Rewards Pro Credit Card | $99 | $0.00 | −$99.00 |
| Emirates Skywards Rewards World Elite Mastercard | $99 | $0.00 | −$99.00 |
| Korean Air SKYPASS Visa Signature Card | $95 | $0.00 | −$95.00 |
| TD First Class Visa Signature Card | $89 | $0.00 | −$89.00 |
| Miles & More World Elite Mastercard | $89 | $0.00 | −$89.00 |
| Breeze Easy Visa Credit Card | $89 | $0.00 | −$89.00 |
| Wells Fargo Autograph Journey Card | $95 | $50.00 | −$45.00 |
| Wyndham Rewards Earner Pro Card | $95 | $50.00 | −$45.00 |
| MGM Rewards Iconic World Elite Mastercard | $249 | $200.00 | −$49.00 |
| JetBlue Premier Card | $499 | $330.00 | −$169.00 |
| Wyndham Rewards Earner Business Card | $149 | $115.00 | −$34.00 |
| Southwest Rapid Rewards Premier Credit Card | $149 | $120.00 | −$29.00 |
| Capital One SavorOne Cash Rewards Credit Card | $39 | $0.00 | −$39.00 |
| Capital One QuicksilverOne Cash Rewards Credit Card | $39 | $0.00 | −$39.00 |
| TD Cash Secured Credit Card | $29 | $0.00 | −$29.00 |
A $0 counted column does not mean a worthless card. It means the card's value lives in points, miles, free nights, and status — things this audit refuses to price. Those cards aren't failing a test; they're declining to take it in dollars, and you should hold them (or not) for what their own currency is worth to you.
Run this audit on your own wallet, all year
This page is a snapshot of face values. Your real audit is personal: which of your cards' credits did you actually use before they reset? That's the number that decides whether a fee was worth it — and it's the number Card Alarm keeps for you, card by card, cycle by cycle, without ever asking for your bank password.
Fees and benefit details verified against issuer-published card information, October 2026. The catalog behind this audit covers 238 cards and 357 benefits; this page audits the 76 cards that charge an annual fee.
What's your number?
There's money sitting in your wallet right now. Tap your cards, see your number — thirty seconds, no account needed.
Find my number →The calculator is free — tracking is Pro. Every plan starts with a 3-day free trial; Pro is $100/yr or $20/mo — one flat price for everyone — with a 30-day money-back guarantee.